Reply To: Homogenizing antiX19 User Interface (proof of concept)

Forum › Forums › General › Screenshots › Homogenizing antiX19 User Interface (proof of concept) › Reply To: Homogenizing antiX19 User Interface (proof of concept)

#21368
Anonymous

    With all due respect but, maybe you should consider changing the title to:

    Homogenizing antiX19 User Interface (proof of VERY BAD concept)

    1. If one’s installing Fluxbox / IceWM / JWM, one has a good reason to do so
    (There’s no good reason to install them all at once but, that’s allowed too)

    If you make them all look same — why not keep only one and remove the rest?
    (OpenBox will do almost the same, if you add all what you plan to add here.)

    2. You are designing a memory hog that’s quiet the opposite of “mean & lean”.

    3. I could now start explaining why and what to do and what not and why but, i’ll just tell it in 5 screenshots.

    1st screenshot — That’s pretty but, not very usable
    2nd screenshot — That’s OK look but, good usable (that said, if it would work as designed)
    3rd screenshot — That’s good looking AND has excelent usabillity (understand it as a reference for ‘how to do it right’)
    4th screenshot — That’s the Nr. 3 again but, this time only Start Menu (doesn’t fit on single screenshot)
    5th screenshot — That’s the Nr. 4 but this time, with alphabetic menu instead of list

    You managed to produce quiet the oposite: it doesn’t look good and it’s unusable.

    Tipp:

    Concentrate on usabillity: No black themes, no transparency under 90 ~ 95 %, high text contrast and good fonts legibillity.

    Further reading:
    http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2014/10/color-contrast-tips-and-tools-for-accessibility/

    Icons and themes for the inspiration:
    http://www.noobslab.com/p/themes-icons.html
    http://b00merang.weebly.com